Now available: all four parts of my analysis of In Sinu Jesu

Click here to read all four parts of my analysis of the popular spiritual book In Sinu Jesu on Where Peter Is.

Part 2 of my critical analysis of In Sinu Jesu appears on Where Peter Is

Today Where Peter Is published part 2 of my critical analysis of In Sinu Jesu. In it, I further examine how the book came to be written, with a special focus upon the unusual circumstances under which it received approval from the censor appointed by the then-bishop of the Diocese of Meath. Parts 3 and 4 will appear tomorrow morning and Friday morning, respectively.

Where Peter Is publishes my critical analysis of In Sinu Jesu

When the popular spiritual work In Sinu Jesu was published in late 2016, I paged through it in a bookshop and thought it was a pleasant, if rather intense, apologia for Eucharistic devotion. Recently, however, a conversation with a priest friend led me to take a second look at the book of alleged private revelations given to an anonymous "Benedictine Monk."

The priest told me about some serious pastoral issues occurring in his diocese; the bishop had disciplined a few priests who were promoting spiritually harmful practices. I asked whether the priests involved were reading a particular book, and was told that they were. It was In Sinu Jesu.

I therefore decided to read the book in depth. What I found led me to conclude that a critical analysis of it was necessary so that those who might be attracted to its Eucharistic spirituality would be able to distinguish between what is true and laudable and what is erroneous and potentially dangerous.

My analysis of In Sinu Jesu will appear in four parts on Where Peter Is. Yesterday part 1 appeared; each day this week is to see a new installment until the fourth and final one appears on Friday. I pray that this analysis begins a needed theological and pastoral discussion of the work.